Open-world RPGs offer a lot of player freedom ^77%

Truth rate: 77%

Pros

Players can explore entire worlds ^{53% (+80)}

Non-linear gameplay is a characteristic ^{28% (+80)}

Analysis paralysis occurs when too many options are available ^{73% (+75)}

Character development and customization exist ^{70% (+75)}

RPGs with too much freedom can be tedious ^{92% (+50)}

Non-linear gameplay makes the story hard to follow ^{74% (+50)}

Multiple story paths are available ^{69% (+50)}

Players can explore entire worlds ^53%

Impact:

+80

In these games, players are given the ability to roam freely across vast landscapes and environments, allowing them to discover new locations and experience different cultures. This level of exploration often provides a sense of immersion and engagement, as players feel they have been given a genuine opportunity to uncover secrets and make their own choices. As a result, players can develop a strong emotional connection with the game world and its inhabitants. The freedom to explore also allows for a more dynamic and unpredictable experience, as players are able to stumble upon unexpected events and opportunities. This open-world design enables players to create their own adventure and play style.

Non-linear gameplay is a characteristic ^28%

Impact:

+80

In games with non-linear gameplay, players can choose their own path and make decisions that affect the game world and story. This allows for a high degree of freedom and flexibility, enabling players to explore different areas, interact with various characters, and experience the game in unique ways. The lack of strict linearity means that players can approach challenges and objectives from multiple angles, making each playthrough potentially distinct. Non-linear gameplay often requires players to think critically and strategically, as they navigate complex scenarios and make decisions with significant consequences. This characteristic is a key aspect of open-world RPGs, enabling them to offer a rich and immersive experience for players.

Analysis paralysis occurs when too many options are available ^73%

Impact:

+75

In games that provide an abundance of choices and freedom, players may experience mental gridlock due to the overwhelming number of possibilities. This can cause hesitation and indecision, as individuals struggle to weigh the pros and cons of each option. The sheer variety of actions and outcomes can lead to a feeling of being unable to make a choice at all, resulting in missed opportunities and unfulfilled potential. As players become paralyzed by the numerous options available, they may feel frustrated and disconnected from the game experience. This phenomenon highlights the delicate balance between offering player freedom and avoiding overwhelming decision-making responsibilities.

Character development and customization exist ^70%

Impact:

+75

This aspect allows players to shape their characters' abilities, appearances, and personalities to fit their playstyle. The depth of customization can range from simple choices like hair color and clothing, to complex systems where players can craft or enchant equipment. Some games also offer branching skill trees that enable players to specialize in specific areas or create unique hybrids. This flexibility can lead to multiple playthroughs with distinct characters, each tailored to a different approach or role. By giving players agency over their character's development, the game encourages experimentation and creativity.

RPGs with too much freedom can be tedious ^92%

Impact:

+50

The amount of freedom given to players in an open-world game can sometimes lead to unnecessary exploration and repetition, making the gameplay experience feel tedious. Without clear direction or objectives, players may wander aimlessly, losing interest in the game's story and mechanics. This excess freedom can also result in players feeling a lack of accomplishment or satisfaction upon completing tasks, as there is no sense of progression or challenge overcome. As a consequence, games with too much player freedom might become tedious to play through, failing to engage players and detract from their overall enjoyment.

Non-linear gameplay makes the story hard to follow ^74%

Impact:

+50

In such games, the abundance of choices and pathways can sometimes lead to a disjointed narrative, as the player's experience may not be structured in a linear fashion. This can result in a story that is difficult to engage with or fully comprehend. The freedom to explore and create one's own path can, ironically, make it challenging for the game to effectively tell its intended story. Furthermore, the non-linear structure can make it hard for players to become invested in the characters' motivations and emotional arcs. This disconnect can be frustrating for players who are accustomed to a more guided experience.

Multiple story paths are available ^69%

Impact:

+50

In games that feature multiple story paths, players can choose to pursue different narrative threads and character arcs. This allows for a high degree of replayability, as the same game can be experienced in many unique ways. The availability of various story paths often contributes to the sense of player freedom, enabling individuals to create their own personalized experiences within the game world. By offering branching narratives, developers can cater to diverse player preferences and interests, further enhancing the overall gaming experience. This design approach can lead to games that are highly engaging and rewarding for players.

Cons

Linear storytelling is preferred in RPGs ^{78% (-50)}

Players get lost in open-world RPGs ^{42% (-50)}

Dynamic events are common in open-world RPGs ^{49% (0)}

Linear storytelling is preferred in RPGs ^78%

Impact:

-50

In contrast to open-world RPGs, this approach prioritizes a predetermined narrative path. This means that players are guided through the game's story and events in a more structured and sequential manner, rather than being given the freedom to explore and discover things on their own. As a result, the emphasis is on telling a cohesive and engaging storyline, often with a focus on character development and emotional resonance. While this can lead to a more immersive experience for some players, it can also limit their creative input and agency within the game world. This approach may appeal to players who value a strong narrative over gameplay freedom.

Players get lost in open-world RPGs ^42%

Impact:

-50

This phenomenon can be attributed to the vastness and complexity of the game world, which often lacks clear direction or linear progression. As a result, players may find themselves navigating through uncharted territories, leading to feelings of disorientation and confusion. The freedom to explore and discover new locations can sometimes be overwhelming, causing players to lose their sense of purpose and get lost in the process. This issue can be particularly pronounced in games with intricate lore or complex gameplay mechanics, which may not provide enough guidance for the player. Ultimately, getting lost in an open-world RPG can be a sign of its engaging nature and the need for further exploration and discovery.

Dynamic events are common in open-world RPGs ^49%

Impact:

In these games, unexpected and unscripted events can occur at any time, allowing players to react and make choices that affect the game world. These dynamic events can range from simple encounters with non-playable characters (NPCs) to complex and challenging situations that require strategic thinking. As a result, players have increased agency and freedom to explore and interact with the game environment in a more immersive way. The unpredictability of these events also encourages replayability, as different outcomes and consequences are possible each time. This feature is often cited as one of the key characteristics that distinguishes open-world RPGs from other types of games.

Info: